comments 18

Best Roast Chicken

Best Roast Chicken with Nigel Slater's root vegetable tangle

I‘ve had a string of failures in the kitchen lately, new recipes, all of them. There was the savoury tart with pastry so short that it collapsed into crumbs when cut, the new method for making ricotta that produced dry and rubbery curds, and the hazelnut and blueberry cake I baked for dinner with friends that seriously damaged my reputation in the cake department. Saddest of all, despite carefully planning a romantic dinner for a stay-at-home date night, all I managed to serve up was an over-cooked leg of lamb and soupy chocolate pudding (we still ate it, but it wasn’t exactly the culinary seduction I had imagined). Enough experimentation! After all this failure, I wanted a recipe that was tried and true. Enter: roast chicken.

Roast Chicken with Rosemary, Lemon and Garlic

I’m not assuming that any of you needs a recipe for roasting chicken. It’s just chicken, seasoning, a little fat, a hot oven and enough time to turn the juices from bloody to clear – that’s really the only bit you need to get right; beyond that, everyone tends to have their own method. For the longest time I roasted chickens in a moderate oven, basting with juices and wine every 20 minutes. It was a bit fussy and I had to hover in the kitchen, but I was perfectly happy going through life like this until the day I read about Molly Wizenberg’s preferred technique. Intrigued, I gave it a whirl, and the rest, as they say, is history.

Chicken, adorned with butter, salt, pepper and herbs, ready for resting overnight

There is no going back when you learn a new technique. My roast chicken had been perfectly edible, but in my quest for crispy skin I often produced dry meat, despite all that basting. When I followed Molly’s instructions, not only did I get a flavoursome, tender, juicy roast, but the chicken was also covered in golden, crispy skin. It was, and remains, roast chicken nirvana. (An equally enlightening moment was learning that mushrooms are best fried in a completely dry pan. Sauté them until their water is released and cooks off and only then add butter or liquid. Try it; it’s a revelation.)

Golden Roast Chicken

Looking back at Molly’s post now, I can see that I have settled into my own interpretation of some of the finer details, but the points on which I am unwavering are, first, the practice of seasoning the bird inside and out before letting it rest for 24-48 hours. Yes it does take forward planning, but it’s this gentle brining process that is responsible for the soft, succulent meat. Second, the chicken must be roasted at a very high temperature and flipped over twice during its time in the oven. This creates an even roast over the entire chicken and lets the juices run down into the naturally drier breast meat.

Roast Chicken with Nigel Slater's Root Vegetable Tangle

To go with this chicken I made Nigel Slater’s Root Vegetable Tangle (via Lucy at Nourish Me). I don’t like cluttering up the oven with another tray of roasting vegetables, taking heat and air flow away from the chicken. The advantage of Nigel’s Tangle, is that it can be prepared ahead and slipped into the oven the second that you take the chicken out. The finely shaved vegetables will cook and crisp in the time it takes you to rest and carve the chicken (and make gravy, if you are so inclined – I’m not). Cooking truly doesn’t get much better (or more reliable) than this.

(And because I just can’t stop myself from trying new recipes, I used the bones and carcass of the chicken to make bone broth for the first time, using this method. The broth was tasty (win!) but it made our house smell like a soup pot (not good). After two days of being enveloped in a funky haze of chicken-scent we gave up on the idea of “perpetual soup”. Reality is such a let-down sometimes.)

Best Roast Chicken

Adapted from Orangette

1 whole chicken, small-medium size
2 Tbsp butter
2 & 1/2 tsp fine salt
1 tsp ground black pepper
Zest of 1 small lemon
2 cloves garlic
2 Tbsp fresh rosemary leaves

Wash the chicken inside and out with cold water then dry thoroughly with paper towels. Place on a baking tray or in a roasting pan.

Remove the zest of the lemon and pound in a mortar and pestle along with the garlic and rosemary. Add half of the butter, 1 tsp of the salt and half the pepper to the herbs and mash together to combine. Spread this mixture inside the cavity, pressing into the bones to ensure the herbs stick to the cavity.

Mix the remaining butter, salt and pepper together and spread over the exterior of the chicken. Rub and massage the seasoning into the meat, then cover the chicken with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 24-48 hours.

Take the chicken out of the fridge one hour before you want to cook it. Heat the oven to 220°C / 430°F. Place the chicken in the oven, breast side up and roast for 20 minutes. Take the chicken out and, using two long forks, flip the chicken over. Place it back in the oven for 20 minutes, then take it out and flip it over again. Roast for a final 20 minutes. Remove from the oven and rest for 15-20 minutes before carving.


  1. Pingback: The year that was: 2015 | Chez Moi

  2. This looks so mouth-watering! The skin looks crispy and the meat looks so moist. I appreciated you writing about trying new recipes that didn’t work out too–I can relate to that as well! The vegetables look lovely too!

  3. Carol

    Hi Chez, This recipe is very like Stephanie Alexander’s recipe except for the 24/48 hour prep. I might try this though! I am particularly interested in the veggies! Yum!

    • The veggies are so good! Make sure you add in a parsnip or two as their sweetness really adds something. Leftovers lose their crispy edges but are still blissful – scatter over a bit of feta and parsley and call it dinner 🙂

    • Let me know how it goes if you do try it. On reading Molly’s recipe again I noticed that she rubs the salt directly onto the skin without any fat. I must have added the butter all of my own so I’m interested to try salt only next time. Not that I think the recipe needs any improving!!

  4. Michele

    They say we learn from mistakes! So I know you won’t stop experimenting. Yet for all the cookbooks I have, and the recipes I collect from the web, I still return on a regular basis to my 40+ year old Australian Woman’s Weekly Cookbook – coverless, taped together and well travelled!

    This chicken of yours looks tantalizing tho, so I may have to abandon Maggie Beer and give it a try. And the veggies look particularly delish.

    I am enjoying your blogs. One of the joys of joining in late, I am treated to a miriad of great photos and words. A bit like finding a series of books when the author has already published half a dozen!

    • Hi Michele! I wasn’t sure who it was at first but your “tho” gave it away! Thanks for reading and commenting. I’m very glad indeed that you are enjoying reading the blog – it’s my little creative outlet that I rarely talk about in real life. I would love to see your cookbook sometime – I’m quite fascinated by old cookbooks that have become a bit like family heirlooms. See you soon 😊

      • Michele

        I’ve heard of the IT girl, but not the THO lady before! You’re welcome to check out my recipe book collection. I have an old hand written family one too. What I find interesting is that modern cookbooks have seriously upped the sugar content in many ‘old’ recipes. In recent years I purchased a cupcake book … For granddaughters birthday celebrations. Made a recipe and found it heavy and unpalatable. Went back to the old AWW and found a recipe for what we used to call fairy cakes, and all ingredients were identical except for the sugar, which was double the amount in the new book. I checked out all other recipes in the new book and found the same story…. Now wonder we have so many dietry problems.

        Keep up the writing. Good stuff. We all need our secret lives.

      • I agree with you about the sugar content of recipes now – I often try to dial it back. Maybe the book club could do a cookbook session sometime?!

      • Michele

        Brilliant idea. We should address it at your meeting. I am a great believer that bookclubs are about words not rules and regimentation. Oh, and a nice nibble or two. Finished the book today. Excellent. Discussion should be fruitful ( to maintain the culinary theme).

  5. It looks so golden and magnificent! And sometimes it takes a lot of screw ups to finally have an experiment that works like magic, I feel your pain hehe the chicken looks like it was worth it though!

    • Hi Jess, yes there’s always a risk when you try new things so it’s nice to have some foolproof recipes to fall back on. I can always rely on this chicken!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s